Not only Stupid … but Sinister as Well
October 24th, 2008I’ve already voted in the Presidential election. I voted for Obama. McCain’s choice of Sarah Palin as his Vice-presidential running-mate sealed my vote. I tell because I want you to know my bias upfront.
I don’t normally do political blogging. I don’t consider myself exceptionally knowledgeable about politics, and politics is not a major interest of mine. Indeed, although politics cannot be avoided with this story, the point I want to get across is a moral one, not a political one.

This is Ashley Todd. She is a 20 year old Texas A&M college student. She is an ardent McCain supporter. McCain is going to win Ashley’s (and my) home state of Texas quite handily. Obama and McCain know that so there is not much Presidential campaigning going on down here. However, Ashley evidently wanted to be involved in the McCain campaign in a way that could make a difference. So she went to the hotly contested state of Pennsylvania.
This morning on my way to work, I heard that she had been assaulted at an ATM machine by a black man. The black man was offended by her McCain/Palin sticker on her car. He knocked her to the ground, kicked her, and carved a letter B for Barack into her face.
Poor her, right? … Well not so fast. Look at the picture. Yes Ashley has a black eye and the “B” on her face but there are no other cuts or scrapes. The “B” is a scratch. There will be no permanent scarring. It is a well formed letter which would be surprising for something done in anger on a squirming person trying to protect herself from an assault. In fact, the only thing wrong with the B is that it is backwards … almost as though the B were made by someone looking in a mirror.

This is a more recent picture of Ashley. She is being led away in handcuffs … after admitting that she lied. The only person who assaulted Ashley was Ashley herself. What a stupid, stupid girl.
I was young once upon a time. I know that young people can occasionally do stupid things. I remember doing them. I am all for writing off a certain amount of stupidity as necessary for a healthy maturation process. But what I can’t forgive is the meanness inherent in this act.
What was she trying to do? I think the answer to that question is obvious. She was trying to gain sympathy and votes for McCain/Palin. But how was she going to do that? By portraying Obama supporters as crazed black guys willing to cut up white women who support McCain. In short she appealed to about as vile a stereotype as one can appeal to. That is unacceptable no matter how naive the perpetrator. If you have to stoop to this level in order to achieve a goal, then your goal is not worth achieving.
Posted by darwinsbeagle

